The black I've been staring at has been on opera stages: A "Walkure" in Venice, a "Don Carlos" in Vienna and "The Flying Dutchman" at Covent Garden in London. The Walkure gave us a Winterstorm scene where the coming of spring is played out against a black backdrop. Depressing and pointless. The "Don Carlos" was justified in as much as the Spanish Inquisition setting is one of the blackest periods of history. But it was during that performance that I fell to thinking about the abnormality of just looking at black. And how it makes us feel.
Now Covent Garden gives us a new Flying Dutchman. I'm not quite sure why. The stunning and audacious Ian Judge production (1992-2000) gave us a great ship's prow jutting out into the auditorium, blood red sails, a boat that transforms into a spinning room, a spinning room into a harbour. It was bold and beautiful and wildly exuberantly romantic. www.ianjudge.com
And so, in true Covent Garden tradition, they've replaced it with something dull and ugly. They did this with Salome. Sir Peter Hall gave us an opulent, burnished, decadently beautiful and unsettling world. So, after a brief outing, the loony Covent Garden management gave us, instead, Bondy's dull grey import from Paris. They got rid of that and gave us lots of flowing blood in another forgettable production that seemed to be centered around a naked executioner (?!) . Ditto for Eugene Oneguin which went through far too many expensive incarnations, given its infrequent showings, before it arrived at the rather lovely current version.
And now, oh my, the poor old Dutchman gets frogmarched through another operatic black, boring world. The whole thing starts out well enough - during the overture we are confronted with a magical misty gauze that appears to have rain streaming down it. In what may be a coincidence, the curtain billows and folds in such a way that from where I was sitting,a tall dark shadow seemed to form at regular intervals across the gauze. A symbol of the Dutchman? Or just a happy chance of a curtain fold? Behind the curtain a light beams out at us at regular intervals. I got quite excited and anticipated a scene of a great harbour, a lighthouse and those blood-red sails on a black mast approaching in the distance. Yes, I know traditional but take a look at what Judge did with some of those elements. Broadway has never done better.
Covent Garden certainly didn't on Friday. We were faced with a black set. All the guts of the Royal Opera House stage were on display on either side - lighting fixtures, scaffolding etc. The great Bryn Terfel appeared - always a thrilling moment. He was pulling a giant length of mooring rope that rose high up into the wings. For an insane moment I believed that he was going to pull his blood red sails onto the stage. He walked and sang magnificently and pulled. And I waited. After a while I started to wonder if he wasn't just walking an enormous dog or a dinosaur. I started to wait for it to appear. Perhaps it would symbolize, I don't know, the great black dog of the Dutchman's depression? The dinosaur that the Dutchman had become? Whatever it was, it remained in the wings. Damn!
I've obviously been looking at far too many silly productions in my two decades of opera-going. This production wasn't silly - not at all. But it was ugly and depressing and gave not a hint of the great romantic work that this opera is. If you don't want to deal with the romantic nature of the Dutchman, I'd advise staying well away from Wagner's opera. Tim Albery didn't, alas.
He came up with the usual ruse of setting the story in modern times. That's okay but not particularly exciting. Are we so limited in our imaginations that we can't empathize with lives lived before we were born? If the chorus don't look like Amy Winehouse wannabees, is their singing of less power and interest?
But it's the drabness, the sheer ugliness that got me down. The spinners become workers at sewing machines, labouring under a battery of garish and, painful to my eyes, fluorescent lights. The ghost sailors emerge to molest poor old Senta, who has to come on stage and get roughed up in another garishly, fluorescent-lit set. And all the while we gaze at the black and I just longed for some blood-red sails. If nothing else, I suppose all these grim black productions served to teach me how much colour matters in our lives and how powerful it is when well used on a stage.
The singing was magnificent, particularly Bryn Terfel as the Dutchman and the ROH orchestra their usual stunning Wagnerian selves. But another black day at the Garden alas.
